Choosing Between Stable Diffusion, Midjourney and DALL-E
Comparisons of these tools usually turn into a gallery of pretty pictures, which tells you almost nothing about which one suits your work. The useful differences are structural, and they change much more slowly than the model versions do.
- Open weights run locally: total control, no per image cost, needs a good GPU and real setup.
- Subscription creative tools: strong house style, easy to use, monthly fee, everything hosted.
- Integrated assistants: easiest to reach, best at understanding a plain English request, least control.
- Image quality is no longer the deciding factor.
- Whatever you choose, the file still needs finishing in an editor.
The Three Approaches
| Local open weights | Subscription tool | Integrated assistant | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Examples of the type | Stable Diffusion and its descendants | Midjourney and similar | DALL-E inside a chat assistant |
| Where it runs | Your own computer | The provider's servers | The provider's servers |
| Cost model | Free after hardware | Monthly subscription | Included or credit based |
| Setup effort | High | Low | None |
| Control over settings | Total | Moderate | Minimal |
| Privacy of your prompts | Complete | Depends on terms | Depends on terms |
| Volume limits | Your patience | Plan dependent | Usually capped |
| Works offline | Yes | No | No |
Where the Real Differences Sit
Control
This is the biggest practical difference. A local model lets you fix the random seed, adjust how tightly the model follows the prompt, use a reference image, and swap in specialised variants trained for a particular look.
That matters enormously if you need six images that match each other, and not at all if you need one image for a blog post.
Consistency
Subscription tools tend to have a strong house style. Everything comes out looking like it came from the same place, which is a real advantage for a brand and a real limitation if you want something outside that style.
Understanding what you meant
Integrated assistants are the best at taking a plain English request and working out what you actually wanted, because the language model rewrites your prompt before generating. That is helpful when you do not know the vocabulary, and frustrating when you do, because it changes your prompt without telling you.
What You Need to Run One Locally
Worth checking before you commit an afternoon to it.
| Component | Realistic minimum | Comfortable |
|---|---|---|
| Graphics card memory | 6 GB | 12 GB or more |
| System RAM | 16 GB | 32 GB |
| Free disk space | 30 GB | 100 GB or more |
| Time to first image | An afternoon | An afternoon |
If your machine is not up to it, a hosted tool is not a compromise, it is the correct choice. GIMP itself has modest requirements by comparison, covered in the RAM requirements page and the GPU question.
How to Choose
| If this is you | Start with |
|---|---|
| I want one image for a blog post | Anything free with no signup |
| I make images every day for a brand | A subscription tool, for the consistency |
| I need dozens of variations of one thing | A local model, for seed control |
| The material is confidential | A local model. Nothing leaves your machine. |
| I have no idea what I am doing yet | An integrated assistant, then move on when you outgrow it |
| I have an old laptop | Anything hosted |
| I need it to work offline | A local model, and that is the only option |
Our own free generator sits in the no signup category, which makes it a reasonable place to find out whether generated images suit your project at all before you invest in anything.
The Part That Is the Same Whichever You Pick
Every one of them hands you a file that needs work. The problems are identical across all three, because they come from how the technology works rather than from any particular product.
- Text comes out as gibberish. See adding real text.
- Hands and faces need repair. See fixing hands and faces.
- The image looks slightly too clean. See why AI images look fake.
- The resolution is too small for print. See upscaling without losing detail.
That editing work is where the actual craft is, and it is the same in GIMP regardless of which generator produced the file. The full workflow applies to all of them.
Read the Terms Before You Commit
The most important differences between these tools are in the terms of service, which almost nobody reads.
- Can you use the output commercially?
- Does the provider claim any rights over what you generate?
- Are your prompts and images used for training?
- Are your generations public by default?
- What happens to your images if you cancel?
The copyright picture on top of that is unsettled, and covered in the article on selling AI art.
Common Questions
Which one produces the best images?
The gap has narrowed to the point where the question is not very useful. All three families produce good images from a good prompt. The differences that actually affect your day are control, cost, privacy and how much setup you are willing to do.
Can I run a model on my own computer?
If you have a reasonably modern graphics card with 8 GB or more of memory, yes. On an older machine or integrated graphics it will either be extremely slow or will not run at all.
Do I need to pick just one?
No, and most people do not. A hosted tool for quick ideas and a local model for volume work is a common pairing.
Which is best for commercial work?
Whichever one has terms you have actually read and are comfortable with. That matters far more than image quality for commercial use.
Explore on GIMP.cc
Step-by-step GIMP guides for every skill level.
Resize, compress, convert, and check images online.
Answers to the most common GIMP questions.
Share this article: